Showing posts with label Tiny Toons. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tiny Toons. Show all posts

Friday, October 16, 2026

Interview with John Kricfalusi - The Onion (2001)

 Interview by Tasha Robinson.

The Onion / The AV Club, 2001


    Like his mentor Ralph Bakshi, native Canadian John Kricfalusi spent the better part of a decade drawing low-end studio TV cartoons before his big break. Bakshi "rescued" Kricfalusi in 1987, making him an executive director for the fledgling studio that produced the chaotic and controversial New Adventures Of Mighty Mouse. Kricfalusi and partner Jim Smith founded their own studio, Spümcø, in 1988, selling Kricfalusi's brainchild, the beloved gross-out cartoon Ren & Stimpy, to Nickelodeon the next year. The show was a huge hit, but Kricfalusi's constant battles against the network ultimately got him booted from his own series; Nickelodeon retained the rights and continued producing Ren & Stimpy without its creator. Meanwhile, Kricfalusi took some of the show's subsidiary characters to the Internet, where he began producing independent online cartoon series with icebox.com. He returned to television briefly with a couple of special features for The Cartoon Network, including the raunchy Yogi Bear spinoff Boo Boo Runs Wild. These days, Spümcø sells spinoff merchandise and produces animated ads for companies such as Nike, Old Navy, and Quisp cereal. Kricfalusi has several TV projects in development, including more Cartoon Network shorts featuring classic Hanna-Barbera characters, as well as a series for Fox Kids (The Ripping Friends). Kricfalusi recently spoke to The Onion A.V. Club about why modern cartoons, film, music, education, art, and sexual politics are all disgraceful.


The Onion: When will The Ripping Friends air?

John Kricfalusi: This year. I'm not exactly sure. Summer or fall or something. It's about the world's most manly men, four guys who go around the world kicking ass and taking the law into their own hands and making the world a safe place in which to be manly. They're kind of the opposite of what men are brainwashed into being these days. They're like old-fashioned men, before political correctness. You ever see young guys now, where they're all hugging each other and shit like that? Trying to convince the girls that they're sensitive so they can get laid? Pile of crap.

O: Are we talking men from the 1950s, or Neanderthal Man? How far back?

JK: All men before the '70s.

O: You've complained in other interviews about classic cartoon characters becoming artificially nice throughout the '70s, as well. Is this a society-wide problem?

JK: Well, let's not call it "nice." I have nothing against being nice. Political correctness didn't invent nice. Political correctness is a mean-spirited Commie plot, if you ask me. But just one symptom of political correctness is men hugging men, and that's just a ploy anyway, like I said, to get laid, to convince girls that you're sensitive. No guy is really into that, unless he's gay. Which I'm not saying anything against; I'm just saying that naturally, guys don't like to touch each other, except two ways. And one is really hard, with a clenched fist. My dad gave me this theory just last year. He was railing on and on. [Adopts gruff, hoarse voice.] "I go down to the mall, and I see these young guys, you know the kind, they got the earrings and the long hair and those giant pants, looks like they're wearing a tent? They're down there hugging each other. They're disgusting." He was telling me about this guy on his dart team, one of these touchy-feely guys. [Gruff voice.] "Got his hand on your shoulder, he's slapping your butt. One time I turn around and he slaps me on the butt, and I put both my fists in his face, and I said, 'You try that again, I'm gonna black both your eyes.' And this guy was, like, 30 years younger than me, and you know what he did? You'd think he would take a swing at me, right? No, he sat down and he started to cry! What kinda men are they makin' these days?" "You got me, Dad. I'm going to do something about it. I'm going to make a cartoon that cures kids."

O: And you're going to put it on network TV. It's interesting that you're going back to working for them after all your problems with networks. Do you still think the Internet is the future of animation?

JK: Oh, yeah, Internet animation is my favorite thing. Unfortunately, with this Internet crash, it affected everybody--people who were actually doing real businesses, as well as the people doing bogus businesses to raise money through stocks. So now, for the time being, a lot of people don't have very much confidence in the web. But I think it's only a temporary thing. When you think about it, content online, on a widely known scale, is only about six months old. So it's kind of funny for people to doom something that just got started. But it's the typical thing in the press.

O: What's the status of your online series Weekend Pussy Hunt and The Goddamn George Liquor Program now that icebox.com has folded?

JK: We'll put them up on realcartoons.net.

O: Is that a subsidiary of, or related to, Spümcø? Right now, it looks like it's just part of your site.

JK: It's only related in that I started both of them, but of course Spümcø will be the main supplier of cartoons to the site in the beginning.

O: When are those series likely to reappear online?

JK: I don't know, maybe a month. I don't know if I just want to give them away. I have to find a sponsor or some way to pay for the productions.

O: What about your updates of Hanna-Barbara cartoons? Were those your idea, or The Cartoon Network's?

JK: I've been doing it since I was a little kid, on my own. I loved all cartoons, but for some reason there was something about the early Hanna-Barbera cartoons, like Yogi Bear, Huckleberry Hound, and Quick-Draw McGraw. They ran those three cartoons every afternoon, along with Beany And Cecil. So those were my favorite cartoons at the time. I just sat there drawing them all day. And I went out and bought all the coloring books and all the comic books. In the comic books, they'd show you how to draw the characters. They'd have a grid with a character's head, and it would say, "Now you, Junior, can draw your own grid and fill it in, and then you get Lumpy Bunny!" So I'd do that, and that style became ingrained in me. For years, I would just draw my own stories with those characters. Even when I went to high school and got rebellious like everybody else, I just drew rebellious versions of Hanna-Barbera cartoons. I was a skinny kid, not athletic or anything, but I wanted to go to the parties with the football players and stuff. And to make sure I didn't get my ass kicked, I would have to be the life of the party. So I'd be telling jokes, or drawing this strip I called Cave Newts that I used to do in high school, which was dirty stories with the Flintstones. I'd take their personalities, and the environments and types of stories they did, and exaggerate them. And meanwhile, as I was doing that, on Saturday-morning cartoons they would make re-dos of classic cartoon characters. But they would take out everything that made them popular in the first place. Like, Yogi Bear was a rascal, right? He went around filching picnic baskets. He didn't want to get caught. So kids identified with him: "Oh, that's cool, he's getting away with stuff!" In the '70s, all of a sudden he's in charge of cleaning up the environment, which is the total opposite of his personality. They made Fred Flintstone nice, but when he first started, he was a complete asshole. So they basically destroyed all the characters. About... I don't remember what year it was, '95 or something like that? Fred Siebert started up this program at Hanna-Barbera, where they would do six-minute shorts like the old days, and he would look for new directors and new series that he could develop out of the shorts. I showed him my fucked-up drawings of Hanna-Barbera characters, and he thought that was funny. I said, "I don't know how radical you're going to be here at Hanna-Barbera, but if you really wanted to do something wacky, I would love to make cartoons in this style at Hanna-Barbera. And my cartoons are actually going to be a lot closer to the original Hanna-Barbera cartoons than the recent Hanna-Barbera cartoons were, the ones where they were bastardizing the personalities, having everybody get along and share and all that stuff."

O: Didn't you start your animation career in the late '70s working for Hanna-Barbera and Filmation?

JK: Yeah. They weren't doing those characters at that time, or at least I wasn't working on them. I was working on the really, really hideous stuff, like Fat Albert And The Cosby Kids. But actually, the first cartoons I worked on at Filmation were re-dos of Mighty Mouse and Heckle & Jeckle. So that was my introduction to ruining old characters that I loved when I was a kid. The next year we ruined Tom & Jerry and Droopy, and a few years later I got to ruin The Jetsons. I actually tried to save it while I was working on it, but it was pretty hard, because the whole thing was set up to ruin them. They sent me overseas, to Taiwan, to supervise the production of 15 episodes of The Jetsons there. I was kind of out of sight, so I did my best to make the drawings cool, at least.

O: Was that the series with Orbitty, the little white blobby--

JK: Ahhhh! You see what I mean? They invent these characters in a completely different style that has nothing to do with [the original characters]. Orbitty was there because E.T. had just hit it big a couple-something years before, and they wanted to make sure that the kids liked The Jetsons. They figure the Jetsons would be too old-fashioned by themselves, so they say, "Let's get this ugly character in there! E.T.'s really ugly, but the kids loved him, so we'll put an ugly character in here!" Ouch. Every chance I got, I'd have Astro accidentally step on his head, get him crushed under the couch. Everything I could do to get that thing out of the way.

O: How did you make the transition from Filmation to working with Ralph Bakshi?

JK: He saved me. He saved the business for cartoonists. I'd just finished the Jetsons thing. I came back, waiting to be hailed as... I thought they'd have a parade waiting for me. "John went and put jokes in our cartoons! He's going to be our hero!" I thought there'd be a big party for me, but instead, a lot of people were mad at me for putting jokes in the show and making it lively. So I was out of a job when I got back. I didn't get fired, exactly; they just didn't give me another job. So I was getting depressed. Cartoons were getting uglier and uglier, and I was moping around the apartment. And one day I got a call from Hanna-Barbera that said, "Some guy named Ralph has been calling, wants your phone number. We don't normally give phone numbers out, but he says he's a friend of your dad's, and your dad is really sick, in the hospital. Should we give him your number?" "Uh, yeah, okay!" The only Ralph I've ever met is Ralph Bakshi, so I thought, "I bet this is Ralph Bakshi, pulling a fast one." Sure enough, I call his number, and it's Ralph. [Adopts deep, gravelly voice.] "Sorry about that message, but the only way I could get a-holda ya was to make up some story! You're not pissed, are ya?" "Nah, that's okay, I'm just glad my dad's not dead." Ralph had retired for a few years. He got disgusted with the business and had retired, maybe three or four years before. [Gravelly voice.] "I'm comin' outta retirement! I'm gonna start a TV cartoon studio this time--fuck features! We're gonna be partners, 50/50, you and me, buddy! 'Cause you're the funniest guy I ever met! All right, I'm comin' out." "Uh, okay." He goes, "Wait a minute. Describe yourself to me!"

O: So you'd never met in person?

JK: No, we had met! He wasn't sure he had the right guy when he called me. "Describe yourself to me!" "I don't know, I'm about 5'11", skinny, kinda pasty-looking..." "All right, all right, that's you, Johnny! I'm comin' over!" A couple days later, at seven in the morning, bang bang bang bang, an elephant knocking at my door. I come to the door in my pajamas, "Uhhh..." "Johnny, yeah, that's you! We're gonna be partners, 50/50! C'mon, let's go, put your clothes on, we're startin'!" So he rented a space down on Ventura Blvd., above an old clothing store. We developed something like six Saturday-morning cartoons, wrote a script for a movie... It was really funny: It was called Bobby's Girl, a sort of '50s teen-comedy thing. Those were sort of popular in the '80s. Anyway, we couldn't sell anything. In those days, you couldn't sell a cartoon unless it was pre-sold. No matter how good the concept was, all the executives in the Saturday-morning cartoon business wanted to play it safe. And their idea of playing it safe was, you had to do a show based on a toy, like He-Man or G.I. Joe, or you did something based on a well-known property like Spider-Man or whatever. You couldn't sell anything original. And you really couldn't sell anything that was cartoony. No one understood what cartoons were. You watch those '70s Hanna-Barbera cartoons and there's a million of them, Penelope Pitstop and all that. Scooby Doo is typical of the non-cartoony cartoon style, where nothing cartoony ever happens.

O: When you say "what cartoons were," what do you mean?

JK: What makes a cartoon a cartoon is that it can do things that you can't do in any other medium. Just like any medium. What makes music music is melody and rhythm, and a million variations on those things--a pleasant melody, normally, unless you're talking about modern music. If you took those out, it wouldn't be music anymore. So in cartoons, what makes it cartoony is that you're doing things that are impossible to do. You have characters that have strong personalities, but they can do crazy things. If you watch a Bugs Bunny cartoon, they squash and stretch and make funny expressions, and they do all kinds of things that you laugh at, visually. You couldn't do anything like that in the '70s or '80s. It was against the law. They thought you were crazy if you did anything like that. They said, "The way you're drawing, the character looks weird!" Well, it's supposed to look weird. It's a cartoon. I swear, all the people in charge of cartoons had never seen a cartoon before except for the '70s ones.

O: Why do you think the industry changed so much in the '70s?

JK: Well, a lot of things happened. The thing everyone blames is that TV cartoons are a lot cheaper than theatrical cartoons, and that's true, and that's obviously going to hamper the quality considerably. But [early TV] cartoons were still cartoony. The characters still did impossible things; they just didn't do them with full animation and as many backgrounds. They just cut down on the production values. That was because those cartoons were still made by cartoonists. By about 1964, [CBS network executive] Fred Silverman had invented the concept of doing Saturday-morning cartoons, where you had a whole block and ran cartoons back to back. And once he did that, the demand for cartoons rose considerably. All three networks started up their own Saturday-morning programs. They had to produce a million cartoons, faster and more than they had ever done before. And all the cartoonists who had done the classic cartoons were starting to get old, and there weren't enough of them to go around. So they just started hiring people off the street. There was a big dearth of writers. People who could draw at all were really valuable by that time. People who could write, nobody gave a shit about. They started giving writing jobs to people who were driving trucks the week before, gofers, film editors. And all of a sudden, hordes of complete amateurs are writing cartoons. And while that happened, we started getting these executives in the Saturday-morning cartoons that were basically somebody's secretary, because nobody really wanted to be in charge of Saturday-morning cartoons. Everybody wants to be in prime time, right? So you have people who didn't know anything about cartoons, about entertainment... They were just stenographers or something, they're in charge of the decisions, and we have people with no experience writing the cartoons. They take over. Now, the most imaginative art form ever created is the least imaginative art form. That killed creativity in cartoons. From about the mid-'60s until about 1990, it was the worst form of art ever created.

O: So cartoons have improved in the last decade?

JK: Yeah, they've gotten considerably better since Mighty Mouse. That was what started the whole change.

O: What was different about how Mighty Mouse was produced?

JK: It was the first series that was completely created by cartoonists: It was written by cartoonists, all the creative decisions were made by cartoonists, and we created all the characters. It was totally different from anything anybody had done. We broke every rule you could think of, everything they told you that you couldn't do. I used to, once in a while, have characters turn to the camera and say something. They used to tell us, "You can't break screen direction. You'll lose the audience, and the kids won't believe in the characters anymore." I said, "Have you seen Bugs Bunny or anything, or Popeye, where he turns to the camera and says something funny before he pops his can of spinach open?" They said, "No, no, kids are more sophisticated today." Anyway, we did that once in a while on Mighty Mouse, and that spawned Tiny Toons. A whole bunch of things we did once or twice on Mighty Mouse became whole trends in other people's cartoons. Everybody copied it instantly. Tiny Toons was founded on not only the types of jokes we were doing in Mighty Mouse, but they also hired half our staff. And they swore they were going to use the same system we were using--the director system, the unit system--where directors would write their own stories, or supervise the writing, and follow the production through from beginning to end. Which is the opposite of how Hanna-Barbera did cartoons at the time, or Filmation, or DIC, or anybody. Tiny Toons took everything we tried in Mighty Mouse that didn't work. They took all our mistakes, and created their own style around them.

O: You've certainly gone on record before about not particularly caring for Tiny Toons.

JK: It's terrible. It's absolutely horrible. The director system didn't last long. Producers were losing control, executives were losing control, because all the artists wanted to do their own thing, like we did on Mighty Mouse. So gradually all the writers snuck back in... You should put quotes around "writers," because they're not real writers. People who write cartoons are not real writers. They'd all rather be writing movies or sitcoms, or something like that, but they're not good enough. These are people who can't construct a sentence, let alone a plot. And if you watch Tiny Toons, it's like watching an 11-year-old in front of the class on Red Cross Day, trying to tell a joke. Telling it badly and, when he gets to the punchline, saying, "Did you get it? You get it? Well, let me explain it to you, 'cause you didn't laugh." They do that in Tiny Toons all the time. Somebody will walk off a cliff, look down, and then fall. And when they hit the bottom, they say, "There is an unwritten cartoon law that if you don't see that you've stepped off a cliff, you won't fall, but as soon as you see that you've stepped off..." Shut up! You don't have to explain it! We got the joke when we saw it 50 years ago, when it was invented! It just drives you crazy, watching that stuff. It's so obnoxious.

O: Did you have to fight CBS to get Mighty Mouse done your way?

JK: I had no contact with the network past the first week. It was really funny, because Ralph had convinced them that we'd developed Mighty Mouse as a show and we had the rights to it, and we didn't. He was in a meeting where we were pitching all the shows that we'd developed, and they told him, "I'm sorry, we really like all these shows, but we can't buy them because they don't have any marquee value." And he blew up. He had one of his famous explosions. He spit out his cigarette at them and screamed at the top of his lungs, "Marquee value? You want fucking marquee value? You're talking to me, Ralph Bakshi, king of animation, about marquee value?" Scared the crap out of them. He's a very large guy, super-strong, and he's been known to hurl... I've seen him pick up desks and throw them across the room. And he has perfect aim, too, absolutely dead-perfect aim. You don't want to fuck with Ralph. So he starts screaming at them, and they were scared, right? They told him, "Honestly, Ralph, if you had a character that was safe, that everybody knew, we'd buy the show from you. We really want to buy one of your shows!" He goes, "I'll give you fucking marquee value!" "Well, who you got, Ralph?" "Mmmm... Mighty Mouse!" He remembered the first job he ever worked on was at Terrytoons in the mid-'50s, and just spit out "Mighty Mouse." They said, "Okay, we'll take it, just please leave the room and don't kill us!" So he gets to the car, races back to the studio, and tells his partner, "Find out who the hell owns Mighty Mouse, quick!" Then he goes over to my house, because we'd finished all our development and were just trying to figure out whether we were ever going to get a job. And he pounds on my door on Saturday morning, again at like seven in the morning, yelling, "Johnny, get out of bed! I sold Mighty Mouse, let's go! We've gotta have a studio by next week! We need 35 people and 13 scripts!" So I got on the phone and called everyone I knew who hated working on Saturday-morning cartoons, all the disgruntled artists, and raided a bunch of studios. They left in droves, and by Monday we had a studio. We wrote, like, 20 stories in a week. And the following week we started production. It was a crazy, crazy time, with everybody working 15-hour days, all sorts of personality conflicts, everybody getting in each other's way, but somehow we pulled it off and made this weird show.

O: And you never heard any feedback from the network until they pulled the plug on the show over the cocaine controversy? [Mighty Mouse was canceled due to a flap revolving around the character sniffing a flower for energy. --ed.]

JK: That was two years later. I wasn't even there anymore. I heard that on the radio. I was working on Beany And Cecil over at DIC. I was only there for the first season of Mighty Mouse, though I should have stayed with it. You know better later, I guess. A lot of the trends of today came directly from that show.

O: And from Ren & Stimpy. If Mighty Mouse was the start of cartoons being cartoony again, Ren & Stimpy set the standard for gross and confrontational humor.

JK: That was a direct line through me. Everything that I did wrong in Mighty Mouse, and we did a lot of things wrong, I swore I wasn't going to do on Ren & Stimpy. So I left that to Tiny Toons. They took over the mistakes. I got rid of all the self-conscious stuff, the sporadic storylines, and not being able to stick to a character. I went off and said, "I'm going to pick some star characters and really develop their personalities and stick with them." So I stuck more to the stories on Ren & Stimpy, and less to the anarchy of Mighty Mouse. Ren & Stimpy seems anarchic, but what holds it together is the definite conflict between the main characters. That didn't exist with Mighty Mouse, which was more like Mad Magazine: Whatever we came up with that was weird, we'd do.

O: Were you just trying to push the envelope, or did you have a specific artistic goal in mind?

JK: Depends on what you mean by pushing the envelope. Some people use that to mean push censorship. Other people just say it's creative, trying to do new things all the time. That's probably more what I like to do. I just like to experiment and not do the same plot over and over. The famous thing among writers on Saturday morning is, they say there are only seven plots, and you interchange the characters. I always thought that was the dumbest thing I'd ever heard. I'm always coming up with new things to try. If I'd doomed myself to seven plots, I would have quit a long time ago.

O: Ren & Stimpy was where you seriously started incorporating '30s, '40s, and '50s styles into your art. How did you develop that visual style? How did it come together?

JK: I don't know. Some of my influences... Bob Clampett, the greatest cartoonist of all time. Chuck Jones is a big influence, and Tex Avery. That's animators. Then there are a lot of comic-strip and comic-book artists. Don Martin... not his drawing style so much as his humor. There are millions of influences. I loved Marvel Comics, though you probably wouldn't see much of that in Ren & Stimpy. If it shows up, it's probably subtle. I'm also a big fan of old movies, so a lot of my visual influences come from Fritz Lang and Billy Wilder and Hitchcock. And early Hanna-Barbera cartoons, which have the simplest, clearest staging in the world. That was really good for me to learn when I was a kid, because it was so clear: When I started my own comics and storyboards, I just used that. And then, as I was influenced by more sophisticated things, I added my live-action influences. Clampett has really sophisticated cutting, and that started entering into my staging. But I always had the solid basis of the simple three-shot cutting and staging of Hanna-Barbera, where they had a long shot, a medium shot, and closeups for reaction. That's the absolute basis of film language. It was admittedly a cheap system, but it also made it clear. Not very many cartoons do that. Particularly Tiny Toons and Animaniacs and all that stuff, which work completely against what's going on. I mean, the stories aren't worth doing anyway, but it's just anarchy. You watch that stuff and go, "Oh, my eyes are sore."

O: What do you think about the MTV editing style that's taken over popular culture over the past couple of decades?

JK: I think it's crazy. It's terrible, out of control. Movies are just a headache to me. You go to a movie and there's no organization, no planning of thoughts. Hand-held cameras, that stuff drives me insane. I keep expecting the camera to drop on the ground or something. Makes me dizzy. Everything's random now. Nobody has any control over anything anymore. All the people I like were in the Age Of Thought. Everything was planned, organized, thought out, practiced, rehearsed. Perfectionism. Now, it's just like, "Throw a bunch of ideas up in the air. Where they land, that's what you get." Every time I go to a movie, I come away depressed. They all look like committee products. Nobody has any skill anymore.

O: What about music, or television? Is anyone producing anything new that you enjoy?

JK: There are cartoons that have elements of things I think are good. Powerpuff Girls has some really imaginative color in it, and that's a first for cartoons. Color has been pretty crappy for the longest time in cartoons. And it's controlled color, not random, very well thought out. A lot of the Cartoon Network cartoons are much better than in the previous decade, that's for sure. Cow And Chicken has absolutely beautiful drawings in it. Then there are some that are just... I'm not going to name them, but they look like three-year-olds draw them. I don't have any interest in that stuff. They're holding back history.

O: Is there any future for network cartoons, or is the future of real cartoons all on the Internet?

JK: The future of everything is on the Internet. Anything that's corporate and large is doomed to be bad.

O: What about something like South Park? Does that give you any hope for independent animators pushing their own vision on cable?

JK: It's not their own vision. What vision? It's a bunch of used Ren & Stimpy jokes. It's the same stuff over and over again. It's all been done. And cartoons have to be drawn well. Every once in a while, people will say, "Hey, did you read this comic book?" "Ah, the drawings were really crummy in that one." "Oh, but the story was great!" I'm sorry, but I can't get past the ugly drawings. If you want a good story, read Hemingway. Some comic writer is going to write better than a real writer? I don't think so. It's not all about the drawings, but it's about the drawings first. I don't say story is not important. But without the drawings, who gives a shit?

O: What about Internet cartoonists? Are there any you think are moving in the right direction?

JK: They're sort of in the same mold as the sitcom cartoons. They're all drawn really primitively, and they're not really about characters, the ones I've seen. They're all really random. We're at the amateur stage right now on the Internet. Anyone who can get online can make a cartoon. It's really easy to use Flash. We need to get to the point where professionals are doing it.

O: What professionals? If you hate everyone producing cartoons these days...

JK: There really aren't many professionals these days. We need a medium that allows people to grow enough to become professional, like we had in the '30s and '40s and '50s. Because there are no schools that teach anybody anything useful anymore, as far as art goes, or storytelling, or anything like that. It's something that has to evolve like it did in the early 20th century. There are people who are good artists in animation. The storytellers have yet to rear their heads.

O: Do you think the presence of the Internet can make that possible, or is some kind of formal education or mentoring system necessary?

JK: Education would be nice if it were real education, but that's gone out of fashion. Now it's hippie education, the everybody-is-creative theory. You just summon your creative soul out of the dust or something, instead of them sitting you down and teaching you, "Okay, here's how composition works. Here's how anatomy works. Here's how you incorporate your knowledge of composition and anatomy into the work you're doing professionally." There's no school like that today. There are no standards anymore. All you have to do is open up a magazine from the 1930s or '40s and just look at the illustrations, and your jaw will hang limp. Every illustration--even the cheesiest ones, like the underwear ads--is drawn a thousand times better than the best fine art is today. It was a time of greatness. Everyone was really good at what they did in the '30s, '40s, and '50s. Now, you have the Age Of Amateurism. It's not to say that there aren't people with talent, but it's very hard to develop your talent, or you have a very one-sided talent, because there's nobody to tell you what your weaknesses are, so you only develop your strengths. And that's including me. We just don't have the same situation people did 60 years ago.

O: Of course, 60 years ago, you never would have been able to get away with most of the things you animate.

JK: You can't get away with Bugs Bunny today. They cut the hell out of Bugs Bunny. You can't see Bugs Bunny cartoons intact on TV. We're way more restrictive today than they were then. A lot of the stuff that was allowed then isn't allowed today. You can't have slapstick anymore. They call it violence now. I had a meeting a while ago where I had someone hitting someone on the butt with a frying pan. We couldn't do it, because it was "domestic violence," so kids having an abused childhood would cry because they saw a cartoon character hit another cartoon character. That's how insane we are. We're not any more liberal than we were 60 years ago. Just certain things are not taboo now that were taboo then. But most things that weren't taboo then are taboo now.

O: Your Internet work--Weekend Pussy Hunt in particular--certainly covers a lot of material that was taboo then and is still taboo now.

JK: Well, I always find what the taboos are, and I'll try to break them. That's part of my personality. But that's not what holds it together. Without the personalities of the characters and the intense situations... If anything characterizes my style, it's the intense emotional content of the characters' interactions. That's what I try to do more than anything else, to make the characters really believe in their motives.

Monday, July 18, 2022

"John Kricfalusi on... Bad Cartoon Writing"

 


Animation Magazine - Issue #29 May/June 1994

Click each image to enlarge. Text version included below.




Text Version:

We're tiny, we're toony. We're all a little looney,
And in this- cartoorty, we're invading your TV.
We're comic dispensers, We crack up all the censors
On Tiny Toon Adventures it's a dose of come-dee..

They're furry, They're funny. They're Babs and Buster Bunny...
...There's Hampton, and Plucky, Dizzy Devils yucky...

Since this series of articles is intended to promote the idea that funny drawings are the most important elements of cartoon entertainment, you might wonder why I spend so much time talking about writing.
Only because it has become the source of our medium's biggest problems.

    Today, when animation or cartoons are discussed at all seriously, too many people talk about how the most important aspect in a cartoon is the story. Almost inevitably the very people who champion story and good writing are the people who practice it the least — modern cartoon writers.

    Of all the media that have ever used any kind of written material, surely Saturday morning cartoons (and their offspring, modern cartoons in general) have the poorest standards of writing skill in the history of human creative endeavor. This is moderately understandable, because animated cartoons don't naturally attract good writers, they attract good cartoonists. Novels, journalism and movies are more likely to attract serious skilled writers. However, cartoons need to get their ideas from somewhere.

    Because modern studio heads are not cartoonists, they tend to think they need writer-writers, no matter how poor the quality, or low the intelligence of this human lor. These executives in charge of animation never think to look for writers among the actual practitioners of the medium — the cartoonists. They would rather settle for someone who admittedly can't draw, but is willing to take a low-level writing job, even if it is only on a cartoon.

    What is a writer? A person who has ideas and the skills to communicate them in words. The medium of writing is the medium of words. It is only a medium, not an end in itself.

    There are other ways to communicate ideas — with paint, with film, with architecture and on and on. Do painters use writers or do they create their own ideas and execute them? Who "wrote" "The Execution of the Rebels on 3rd May, 1808"? Francisco de Goya like other artists, communicated his ideas in the medium he was expert in, in this case the medium of painting. Modern cartoons get their ideas from people who are not able to actually use the medium.

    It's as if you needed a sculpture but instead of hiring a sculptor and asking him to come up with an idea to sculpt, you hire a "sculpt writer" whose job it is to describe a sculpture on paper, then you hire someone with actual talent and skill to try to make some kind of artistic sense out of it. What kind of self-respecting "writer" would take money (more money than the sculptor) for writing sculptures? Certainly not anyone who actually had something to say of his own and the writing dexterity to say it with. This kind of job could only attract charlatans, con-men, door-to-door radio salesmen and once in a while, the honestly ignorant.

    This is exactly the situation we have in animated cartoons today; people unskilled in the medium of animated cartoons (yet well versed in the arts of chicanery) supply the ideas.

    Interestingly, cartoon writing has developed a pattern of incredible predictability. I'd like to point out some cherished techniques of Bad Cartoon Writing that have devolved down to us over the last few decades.

    If you would like to pursue a career in legal swindling, memorize these simple mistakes and you can make between $3,000 to $5,000 a week or almost triple what the cartoonists make, and you can help further destroy our art form in the process.

    1. Too Much Plot

    As I've pointed out in previous issues, the more plot you have in a cartoon, the less time you have for entertainment. Remember, cartoons have finite lengths, whereas novels do not. The Novel is the perfect medium for plot. Cartoons aren't.

    All cartoon script writers write stories that are just too long. The only way to get every story point a writers writes into a cartoon is to chop out all the entertainment value. And even then, it's still too long. There is no time left in the cartoon to use acting or even just plain funny drawings. Here is a tip to
scriptwriters: Scripts take about one minute per script page to perform. And that is tight. If a cartoon is 20 minutes long, don't write more than 20 pages of material. Usually scriptwriters turn in about twice as many pages as the screen time actually allows. This is an absolutely unbelievable waste. Not only for the writer who eventually is going to have much of his material cut out of the picture, long after he
has forgotten what he wrote anyway, but even more criminal is the extra work the artists have to produce for no reason!

    The storyboard will be twice as long as it needs to be. Twice as many layouts will have to be drawn, if someone doesn't catch the problem in the timing stage. Now if an artist is going to spend the same amount of time producing twice as much work, the obvious conclusion is that the quality of the art will go way down, to say nothing of the loss of the artist contributing creative material to the cartoon.

    There is no point in a writer arguing this. He has no direct experience with performance time, whereas animators do. Of course, ideally we shouldn't be writing scripts at all. We should have cartoonists writing storyboards.

    2. Too Many Plots

    Even if we could solve the problem of too much plot we'd still have the problem of too many plots.

    Some writers tend to pride themselves on how many plots and sub-plots they can squeeze into a story. Again, if you have unlimited space in which to tell your story, then that's fine if the writer truly has the skill to weave complex plot elements. (If the writer did have this kind of skill, do you think he'd be writing Tiny toons?) In a finite time-space, the number of plots has to be balanced with the actual
entertaining elements of the story. The more time you spend setting up new plot threads, the less time you have to develop each situation into an entertaining memorable event.

    I see this problem, not only in amateurishly written children's crap, but even in The Simpsons. This cartoon certainly has its moments, and there are usually a few funny lines in each cartoon, but I feel there is much lost opportunity because scenes have to be cut short to make room for sub-plots or sometimes not even sub-plots, but storylines that have nothing to do with each other! I watched one
story that set out to be about Bart's uncle's funeral and halfway through it. Homer came down ill from eating some Polish Sausage or something. This extra story just came out of the blue and interrupted the other story. It was extremely disjointed and both storylines suffered from not having enough time to comfortably tell either story.

    This kind of story plays as if it was written by a committee or staff of writers. Everybody wants to get their ideas into every story. It's a natural tendency. We all do it. It is very hard for a writer to throw out his particular idea. But if the performance is going to suffer because it has to be rushed through, then we need to be tougher editors. A simple solution to this is to spread this wealth of story ideas
over more stories rather than trying to cram them all into one.

    Instead of telling three stories poorly over 22 minutes, tell three stories comfortably over 66 minutes. Crammed stories play crammed. They play like Cliff's Notes — all skeleton and no meat. You will recognize cramming when you see an over reliance on flashbacks. This makes for very awkward transitions and abrupt shifts in narrative. Usually a reliance on flashbacks reveals that the writers just realized they have to fill in a gap to explain where the new storyline came from.

    Remember that the Honeymooners usually had one plot line per half-hour episode, and this is one of the funniest shows in television history.

    Contrary to popular belief, The Simpsons succeeds in spite of the writing, not because of
it. Its appeal lies in its core elements, its fundamental premises, the personalities of the characters, their relationships to each other, the attitude and the graphic look of the cartoon all the elements that its creator, Matt Groening instilled into it. It could profit from more careful traditional writing skills, more of Matt's singular vision and less writing by committee.

    3. Explaining Jokes

    Have you ever heard a cartoon character say, "I'm a cartoon character so I don't have to fall off this cliff until I notice that I'm standing in thin air!" This is the worst kind of amateurish writing. It is an example of a modern "writer" explaining a joke that he doesn't get himself, that someone else wrote long ago, that has been perfectly understandable by the audience for the last 50 years. This shows a lack of confidence in the writer's own ability to tell a joke.

    Another cartoon writers' crime is having the character tell the audience what it's supposed to feel, as in dialogue like, "Aren't I 'wacky'?" Being afraid to let the material stand by itself is something you would expect from a beginning writer, not a highly paid professional. The audience should decide for itself whether material is "wacky" or "funny" or "cool" or however the writer wishes his material to be regarded.

    4. Lack of Professional Confidence

    Amateur writers are understandably afraid that their work won't "work," so they over explain the jokes. They would rather have the characters tell you how zany they are than show you by having the characters actually do something funny. These writers are terrified that their jokes might fail. A confident professional writer or director is willing to take the chance that not everything he does is going to work. I remember legendary cartoonist Eddie Fitzgerald asking Bob Clampett one day about
some of his unorthodox film cuts. "Weren't you afraid that cut might not work?" Clampett looked at Fitzgerald in honest incredulity. "What's going to happen if a cut in a Cartoon doesn't work! Is the world going to end?

    Today, everyone is afraid of every creative idea in a cartoon; that it might "fail." This kind of "safe" thinking has caused the whole art form to fail completely and miserably. A true professional has confidence in his work, confidence that comes from actual hands-on experience with the tools of the medium, in the case of cartoons, experience with entertaining through drawing as well as writing. A pro will be confident enough to try a joke that might fail. If it does, so what? There are plenty more where that one came from.

    5. Unnatural Dialogue

    While I've already mentioned the problem of dialogue spoken with the writer's voice rather than the character's voice, I would like to further mention a related and particularly annoying habit of modern cartoon writers. Writers love to use the characters' mouths to show off the writers' knowledge of obscure trivia, things that only other amateur writers could possibly care about: secrets about the
cast from Gilligan's Island, big pretentious words, names of literary devices like "onomatopoeia" which they don't know how to use and so forth... All this blusteration is just meant to disguise the fact that they don't understand who their characters are and what dialogue is for.

    6. Stealing Movie Plots

    Under the guise of "parody" cartoon writers mask the fact that they have no ideas of their own by "parodying" popular movies over and over again. What's amazing is that they all parody the same movies and just shove their particular characters into somebody else's plot and story. How many Cartoons have we seen that have a title like. "Raiders of the Lost...Duck"? Replace "Duck" with "Bunny" or "Devil" or "Smurf" or "Bart." Replace "Raiders of the Lost..." with "Demolition..." "...Wars" and you have an infinite amount of "free" story premises. Watch next year's crop
of crap for titles like "Jurassic Duck," "Jurassic Bunny," "Schindler's Goofs" and "Jurassic Vacant Cartoon Writer Brains."

    I think that the urge to parody movies is partially an attempt to suck up to movie directors who will hopefully be so flattered that they will give a script deal on something "legitimate" to the writer, enabling her to get out of the miserable cartoon business.

    7. Writing Action That Can't be Staged

    Scriptwriters should not attempt to write physical action. This is something that has to worked out mechanically with drawings. It can't be done in your head, especially if you can't draw. Writers are always writing convoluted action that physically doesn't work. The artists are stuck with trying to make sense of action gibberish, and then the writers complain that the artists ruined their "work." I've heard
more than one writer say, "I'm such a visual thinker. I can imagine all these wild things in my head. If only I could draw, I'd just show you what I mean." There's only one answer for this
kind of talk. "Get off the planet."

    8. Writing Action That Is Too Complicated

    Not having to draw the cartoons themselves, writers have no concern for the immense toil the Artists have to perform in order to put unworkable written ideas on the screen. Writers love to write unbelievably detailed action. Something that sounds impressive on a printed page can amount to
disaster for the artists and the film. I've read countless scripts with idiotic scenes like: "Four hundred mounted Arabs come out of the forest, brushing against the trees. Down shot." One drawing of this would take a good artist weeks to complete. Imagine animating 12 drawings for every second of screen time that the scene is on. This is a practical impossibility. It would take a hundred years to animate such a scene, and for what? To stroke a writer's ego by showing a spectacular scene that took him about half a minute to "write"?

To purposely write stuff that is over ambitious and obviously hard to draw is the absolute height of irresponsibility. The writer is sloughing off the hard work on the artist just because it impresses some network executive who reads the script and imagines The Ten Commandments and gives the writer another fat raise as a reward. Meanwhile the cartoon comes back looking like Hell because the writer didn't do some hard work himself in composing an actual workable cartoon story that utilizes the medium's advantages.

    9. Too Many Characters

    The "too-much," "too-many" syndrome of bad cartoon writing carries over into the characters as well. 

    Modern cartoons usually have too many characters per cartoon. They have "gangs" of
characters in them, all of whom have to be addressed in each cartoon Story. 

    Simple arithmetic will reveal the obvious problem; the more characters you have, the less time you have to spend on each one. This in turn equals less character or personality per character.

    Not only that, but the more characters an artist has to draw in each scene, the less time he will have to draw each character well. Therefore the quality of animation severely drops.

    Cartoon writers need to be taught the "less-is-more" theory. This is more true in animation (which is such a labor intensive art) than even in other artistic mediums. The best way for a writer to realize this is to have to draw his material himself. If every writer in the business had to draw his own scripts for a year or two, they would quickly be cured of many of their irresponsible bad habits.

    Every beginning cartoon writer should be forced to in-between a "crowd scene," so they can see just what is involved. Then they should be forced to design a 'Rube-Goldberg contraption' and lay it out for animation.

    Part of the reason that so much actual drawing in cartoons is done overseas is because too much time and money is wasted on too-long and over-complicated scripts (not to mention, ridiculously overpaid "writers"). Any network or studio executive who might be reading this should realize that when you read these kinds of scripts, your writers are directly cheating you out of quality and production value in your cartoons. You could have more and better artists actually doing work here in the country if your writers would waste less of your studios' time and money.

    10. Celebrities

    Many cartoons today rely on celebrity guest spots.

    There was an episode of The Simpsons that guest starred Aerosmith. The band had nothing to do with the plot of the particular story, they were just there. A lot of screen time was spent on the scene, yet no entertainment value was derived from it. They didn't make fun of the band. The drawings didn't even look like the actual musicians. What were they doing there?

    This too typical instance represents a lack of confidence in original material. The writers feel that their cartoon (the story, the characters, whatever inherent entertainment substance) can't stand by itself. Most cartoon writers are ashamed of having to work on cartoons and so they try to lure in celebrities to lend credibility to the show. The writers are appealing for legitimacy. "You see? It's not just a cartoon! Real people, famous people are in it!"

    11. Defeating the Dramatic Purpose
    
    The term "comedy relief" is a misnomer. It should actually be called "dramatic relief" because that is its function. Comedy relief characters tone down dramatic scenes. 

    Comedy relief characters are not comedic, they are "wacky." They don't make you laugh, they run around with their tongues flopping out and they have crossed eyes. When non-funny people try to be funny, they create "wacky" instead. So what we end up with in cartoons with "comedy relief" characters are stories that are neither dramatic nor comedic. The two elements cancel each other out.

    Disney, after Snow White, began to introduce sidekick characters into his stories. In Sleeping Beauty, Disney created a wonderful villain, Maleficent, the "Fairy of Darkness." She was drawn great. She sounded very menacing. She moved terrifyingly. Sleeping Beauty was potentially a great dramatic story. Disney and his storymen must have thought their villain was "too scary" because they did everything they could to get in the way of her scenes. They surrounded her with "wacky" troll-like bumbling guards. These characters seemed to be out of a whole other cartoon universe, the "Toot Whistle, Plunk and Boom" Disney land. Every time these characters enter the scene, they completely kill the menacing aspect of Maleficent.

    The evil Queen's opponents are the sickeningly sweet and zany three good fairies, Blueie, Pinkie and Mauvie. They further tone down Maleficent's potential menace. The time all these useless extra characters waste could have been better spent developing Sleeping Beauty and the Prince's personalities so that we might care about them when they are truly in danger. The message of all this zaniness is to tell us that the protagonists are never in danger of being in danger. This is purposely self-defeating storytelling. But Walt Disney did it so it must be the right thing to do. For all the great and wise things Walt Disney actually did do for animation, everybody copies his faults instead. Wacky sidekicks are staples of cartoons to this day, while beautiful, well drawn animation is not.

    These faults have magnified to the point of absurdity in modern cartoons. In Alladin, there
are more wacky sidekicks than there are characters whom the story is actually about. The lead character has three wacky sidekicks, a monkey, a Genie and a rug! Jasmine has two sidekicks, her fat father (fat is always wacky) and a boring sidekick (they must have used up their zany budget by the time they got to this character), the Esso Tiger. Worse, Jafar the villain has just about the most irritating "comedy relief character in history, a screaming parrot. The parrot has no purpose in the story's narrative, except to interrupt the atmosphere of the Arabian Nights, the potential dread of the evil Villain and to remind us that the story is not really happening that it's just a cartoon.

    This kind of writing shows a lack of commitment to a firm statement. Is it scary? Or is it funny? The writer who uses "comedy relief" is admitting that he doesn't know what his story is about.

    12. Bastardization

    This is when you take the original premise of something and betray it. For example, what is the premise of Yogi Bear? He's a lazy good for nothing, irresponsible, scheming, pilfering bear. He is basically a fugitive from society, living precariously on the edge of the law. This formula accounts for the initial success of this character and series. Now what is the premise of Yogi's Gang?

    Yogi Bear is a leader of men. He and every other Hanna Barbera character from completely unrelated series have an Ark. You know, like the one from the Hebrew religion? The one that represented Yaweh's murderous vengeful wrath upon all his creations? But this Ark doesn't navigate through water. Of course not. It's a boat. It flies. And what is Yogi's mission? To clean up the environment of course. What else would a lazy, no good pilferer do if he had his way?

    Who could possibly come up with such an unbelievably wrong, preposterous backwards concept? Only an idiot, or more likely a team of idiots — cartoon writers and development executives.

    Another form of bastardization is parasitism. This is when a writer takes someone else's idea and alters it enough to cripple it and call it his own. The current favorite trend of parasitism is exemplified by the "babies" phenomenon: The Muppet Babies, The Tom and Jerry Kids, The Flintstone Kids and so on.

    13. Superbastardization

    Superbastardization is when you mix and match different premise betrayals with parasitism and other bad writing tricks until the premise becomes so twisted that it is beyond any coherent statement.

    The Flintstones movie is a fine example of Superbastardization. It's a big-budget movie stolen from a low budget TV cartoon that itself was stolen and bastardized from a low-budget live-action TV sitcom.

    The current reigning monarch of Superbastardization is Tiny Toons. This goes so far beyond imaginable idiocy that I can barely believe its elements as I describe them. The premise of this series is based upon the classic Warner Bros.' irreverent characters only now they are "cutesy" (as against "cute" or appealing to look at) babies. Every character is a "comedy relief" character, even the ones who were originally straight-man characters. Elmer Fudd is not only zany, he has a vagina now. Let's go further. Glue an exceptionally unirreverent live-action director's name to it, then plug these stolen bastardization personalities into situations not suited for them. For example — into stolen movie plots. Then commit every single other bad writing crime known to man.

    I take my hat off to Tiny Toons. This is a supreme parody of all that's bad about modern cartoons.

    Some of these writing problems are not specific to animation, they've been around for as long as series entertainment of any kind. However, they are usually associated with the decline of a series, when the original team who developed or created a series is replaced by new writers who don't understand the characters, or when the writers run out of ideas that fit the original premise. Or the writers just get tired of writing for the same characters over the years.

    This happens to almost all sitcoms. Get Smart. Max started out as an idiot then became a responsible family man and had to be replaced by Larabee, a new idiot. All in the Family. Archie Bunker became a nice guy. He was visited by Sammy Davis Jr.

    Lucy has to be the worst offender. I can hear her tired old writers after eight years of I Love Lucy. "What do we do with her now?" "I don't know, let's send her to Hollywood. She can meet some celebrities, maybe that will beef up the ratings." Or, "Let's have the characters put on a show! That way they can pretend to be someone else and we won't have to write a new story!"

    What is unique to modern cartoons is that they begin their lives already out of ideas — already at the bottom of a decline. The decadent age of a modern cartoon series starts at its inception in the Story Bible. Today's cartoons are purposely designed to be embarrassing. To get back to the prospect of good cartoon writing, we've seen that "story" or "plot" is obviously a disadvantage to short cartoons (under 20 minutes), however it may not be to longer-form cartoons. This remains to be seen.

    The animation medium (the best of it) and all its clichés and storytelling habits have basically evolved out of shorts. To this day feature-length cartoons have never really gone beyond the short-form cartoon mentality in terms of story, but this is not to say that story can't play a more important role in longer-form cartoons if story-oriented cartoons are ever made. In Disney movies the "story" is quite blatantly less important to the entertainment experience than the fantasy elements, the songs and the ever proliferating sidekicks. 

    All these elements are throwbacks to the cartoons and Silly Symphonies of the 1930s. These vestigial properties take up so much of the time in a typical cartoon feature that there is virtually no time left for "story" in the sense of "plot" and "character development." It's really too bad the Warner Bros.' writers and directors didn't try features. They understood character, and good story really begins with good character. However and if ever it happens, it will take cartoonist-writers with ideas and the skill to communicate them to evolve the medium and develop stories that are suited to the animated feature length cartoon.

In the next issue, John Kricfalusi discusses Bob Clampett's influence on cartoons, the Art of Chuck Jones and the end of Animation's Golden Age. Kricfalusi is the president of Spumco.

The viewpoints expressed herein are those of the author and not necessarily the opinion of the publisher, staff or owner of Animation Magazine.